DECISIONS

OF THE

5, COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

AND OF THE

UNITED STATES COURTS

IN

PATENT AND TRADE-MARK CASES

COMPILED FROM VOLS. 654 TO 665, INCLUSIVE, OF THE OFFICIAL

GAZETTE OF THE UNITED STATES PATENT

OFFICE DURING THE YEAR

For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U. S. Government Printing Office

Washington 25, D. C. - Price $2.00 (Buckram)

COMMISSIONER OF THE UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE

HON. JOHN A. MARZALL

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONERS

HON. THOMAS F. MURPHY HON. ERNEST F. KLINGE, to May 4, 1952

CASES REPORTED

(Decisions of the United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit are indicated by the letter

(a); of the United States Court of Customs and Patent Appeals by an asterisk (*); and of the Supreme Court of the United States by the letter *).]

1 W

*Akerlund et al. v. Marzall, Commissioner of Patents.------
*Allen v. Blaisdell et al.---
*Alligator Company, The v. Larus & Brother Company, Inc.
•American Cyanamid Company V. John A. Marzall, Commissioner

Patents-----
*Anderson, Scinta et al. v.--
*Andrews Deceased, Etc. v. Wickenden.--
Application, In re Commissioner Marzall's Decision, decided June 4, 1952.
Application filed July 24, 1948, In re Assistant Commissioner Murphy's

Decision, decided Mar. 23, 1951.----*Aronberg, In re----------------

106 176

*Babson Bros. Co., Lever Brothers Company, v---
*Barnet v. Wied.---
*Beck, Caldwell, Joseph J. Jr. v---
*Berliner, In re---
•Besser Manufacturing Company et al. v. United S
*Bigelow, In re-----
*Bigelow, In re------------
*Bigelow, In re--------------
*Bisley, In re--------------
*Blaisdell et al., Allen, v----
*Blood, Charles R., In re..
*Blue Lake Producers Cooperative, Etc., In
*Borcherdt et al., In re---
*Bowen et al., In re---
*Broderson v. Marzall, Commissioner of Patents.---
*Brown-Brockmeyer Company (The) v. Westinghouse Electric Corpora-

tion.------

418 143 151 155 298 267 353 121 361

343

5

366

272 93 39

C *Caldwell, Joseph J. Jr. v. Beck -*Campbell Soup Company, Hy-V Company, Inc. v.-------*Christensson v. Hogdal and John A. Marzall, Commissioner of Patents-a Clarkson Manufacturing Company, a Corporation, v. Marzall, Commis

sioner of Patents-----------*Consolidated Cosmetics, Etc. v. Holiday, Inc.--*Cook, Margaret J., John A. Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, v.. *C. 0. Two Fire Equipment Company, Kerotest Manufacturing Com

pany 0--------------------*Cox, In re-----------------------

*Elder Manufacturing Company v. International Shoe Company -----
*Empire Manufacturing Company, Hart Schaffner & Marx, v-.-.
*Eureka Williams Corporation v. Willoughby Machine and Tool Company -

*Foerste, Masciarelli, v-------
Ford, Florence M., Anne E. Hall, Executrix of the Estate of William P.

Hall, deceased, and Joseph Bancroft & Sons Co., Appellants, v. John A.
Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, Appellee.-----

15

*Gazda, In re----
*Goodall-Sanford, Inc., In re...
*Guth, The Edwin F. Company, The Pep Boys–Manny, Moe and Jack, v.

Pago 225 224 331

1

1

*Hart Schaffner & Marx v. Empire Manufacturing Company---
*Hayward, Smith v------
*Helena Rubinstein, Inc. v. Richard Hudnut--------
*Henry Laboratories, Inc., Holland-Rantos Company, Inc. v-
a Hogdal, Christensson v.---.
*Holiday, Inc., Consolidated Cosmetics, Etc. v.---
*Holland-Rantos Company, Inc., v. Henry Laboratories, Inc.
*Honnig, In re---
*Horneman, et al., In re----
*Hy-V Company, Inc. v. Campbell Soup Company----

358 64 91 193

39 285 193

56

125

93

*International Shoe Company, Elder Manufacturing Company,

133

253

253 229 110

*Jacobsen, F. & Sons, Inc. v. Jaybern Fabrics, Inc.-
*Jaybern Fabrics, Inc., F. Jacobson & Sons, Inc., v..
*Jones, In re---
*Jurgeleit, In re-----

к
Kaiser, Donald W., Ex parte, Decision of the Supervisory Examiner Rosa,

decided Dec. 20, 1949:-*Kaufmann, In re------------Kepner, Sanford, v---Kerotest Manufacturing Company v. CO Two Fire Equipment Company.. a Kimberly-Clark Corporation v. Marzall, Commissioner of Patents-------*Kruger v. Resnick.-----------------------------------------------

422

407

27 310

aLarsen v. Marzall, Commissioner of Patents.--
*Larus & Brother Company, Inc., Alligator Company, The, V----
a Lebold, Samuel N. and Morris Paper Mills v. John A. Marzall, Commis-

sioner of Patents-----
*Lee, In re --
*Lever Brothers Company v. Babson Bros. Co..
*Levin, In re-------
*Lightnin Chemical Company, The (The Buckeye Soda

Substituted) v. Royal Home Products, Inc.-*Lindberg, In re--a Lubrizol Corporation (The), Carl F. Prutton, v---*Lundberg et al., In re-----

* Madsen et al., In re-------
*Martin, In re----------
a Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, Akerlund et al. v.---
* Marzall, John A., Commissioner of Patents, American Cyanamid Company

a Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, Appellee, Florence M. Ford, Anne E.

Hall, Executrix of the Estate of William P. Hall, deceased, and Joseph
Bancroft & Sons Co., Appellants, V.-.

------
a Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, Broderson v...
a Marzall, John A., Commissioner of Patents, Christensson v..
a Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, Clarkson Manufacturing Company, a

Corporation, V----a Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, Kimberly-Clark Corporation, v.-a Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, Larsen v.----a Marzall, John A., Commissioner of Patents v. Margaret J. Cook -

34

--------

31 375

35

a Marzall, John A., Commissioner of Patents, Merck & Co., Inc., and Eugene

W. Schoeffel, v.-* Marzall, John A., Commissioner of Patents, National Lead Company v.. Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, Peterson v.--a Marzall, John A., Commissioner of Patents, Samuel N. Lebold and Morris

Paper Mills --* Marzall, John A. Commissioner of Patents, Standard Oil Development

Corporation v.----a Marzall, Commissioner of Patents v. Switzer et al.----------a Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, Taylor, Jr., et al., V---*Marzall, Commissioner of Patents, Vanadium Corporation of America, v:*Masciarelli v. Foerste.---- Merck & Co., Inc., and Eugene W. Schoeffel v. John A. Marzall, Commis

sioner of Patents--*Merritt-Taylor, Inc., v. C. B. Shane Corporation *Miller, In re------Miller, In re---------------------------------------* Miller, In re --*Mission Dry Corporation v. The Seven-Up Company. *Moon, In re----*Moore (Hilltop Laboratories, Inc., Assignee, Substituted) v. Procter & Gamble Company -----

N *National Lead Company v. John A. Marzall, Commissioner of Patents---*Nelson, In re-----New Wrinkle, Inc., et al., United States v------*North Star Manufacturing Co. v. Wells Lamont Corporation ------

232

95

140

1

295

60

236

44 384 411

amonu

VV

80

*Osplack, In re-----

248

--------------------------

331

-------

--------

*Pep Boys, The Manny, Moe and Jack v. The Edwin F. Guth Company
«Peterson v. Marzall, Commissioner of Patents---
Petition of Thomson & Thomson for permission to inspect list of abandoned

Trade-Mark applications, In re Commissioner Marzall's decision, de

cided November 28, 1952----*Poor, In re--*Procter & Gamble Company, The Fred H. Moore (Hilltop Laboratories,

Inc., Assignee, Substituted) v--•Prutton, Carl F., and the Lubrizol Corporation v. John A. Marzall, Commissioner of Patents--------

R *Ray, In re----*Resnick, Kruger v----*Rice, In re-------*Richard Hudnut, Helena Rubinstein, Inc., v. *Rishoi et al., In re--*Rossman, In re---*Royal Home Products, Inc., Lightnin Chemical Company, The (The Buckeye Soda Company, Assignee, Substituted), v.

-

•Sanford v. Kepner-------------
*Schwartz et al., In re---
*Scinta et al., v. Anderson.-
*Seven-Up Company, The, Mission Dry Corporation
*Shackell, In re------
*Shane, C. B. Corporation, Merritt-Taylor,
*Skogseid, In re...
*Smith v. Hayward ---
Standard Oil Development Corporation v. John A. Marzall,

of Patents---------
*Sutherland, etc., In re-----------------------------
Switzer et al., Marzall, Commissioner of Patents v.---

163 232

241

64

20 328 34