THE

SUPREME COURT REPORTER

WITH KEY-NUMBER ANNOTATIONS

VOLUME 35

PERMANENT EDITION

CASES ARGUED AND DETERMINED

IN THE

UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT

OCTOBER TERM, 1914

L

DECEMBER, 1914–AUGUST, 1915

ST. PAUL
WEST PUBLISHING CO.

1915

ALLOTMENT OF THE JUSTICES

OF THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

FIRST CIRCU'IT.
Comprising Maine, Massachusetts, veic llampshire, and Rhode Island.
JUHTICE OLIVER WENDELL HOLMES, of Massachusetts. Appointed De-

Ꭰ
cember 4, 1902, by President Roosevelt.

SECOND (TRCI'IT.
Comprising Connecticut, Veie York, and Vermont.
JU'ATICE CHARLES E. HUGHES, of New York. Appointed May 2, 1910, by
President Taft.

TILIRD CIRCL'IT.
Comprising Delaware, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania.
JUSTICE MANILOX PITNEY, of New Jersey. Appointed March 13, 1912, by
President Taft.

FOU'RTII CIRCI'IT.
('omprising Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, l'irginia, and

West Virginia.
JUHTICE EDWARD I). WHITE, of Louisiana. Appointed February 19, 1991,

by President (leveland; appointed (hief Justice December 12, 1910, by
I'resident Taft.

FIFTII CIRCL'IT.
('omprising Alabama, Florida, Georgia. Louisiana. Vississippi, and Torus.
JUSTICE JOSEPI R. LAMAR, of Georgia. Appointed December 17, 1010, by
President Taft.

HIXTIL ('IRCL'IT.
('omprising Kentucky, Jichigan, Ohio, and Tonne886c.
JCHTICE WILLIAM R. DAY, of Ohio. Appointed February 23, 1903, by Presi.
dent Roosevelt.

SEVESTIL (IRC'I'IT.

Comprising Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin.
JUSTICE JAMES ('. MOREYXOLDS, of Tennessee. Appointed August 29, 1914,
by President Wilson.

Ercilltir ('IRCUIT.
Comprising Arkansar, Colorado, lowa, k'an 8018, Minnesota, Ali880 uri, l'e-
braska, Veir Jerico, Vorth Dakota, Oklahoma, South Dakota,

l'tah, and Wyoming.
JUSTICE. WILLIS VAN DEVANTER, of Wyoming. Appointed December 16,

1910, by President Taft.

XISTII CIRCUIT.
Comprising Alaska, Arizona, California, Harraii, Idaho, Montana, Nerada,

Oregon, and Washington.
JUSTICE JOSEPI MCKENNA, of California. Appointed January 21, 1808, by
President McKinley.
85 S. O.

(vi)

CASES REPORTED

832

Page

Page Adams Exp. Co. v. Commonwealth of Ken- Arkansas ex rel. Norwood, St. Louis Southtucky (238 U. S. 190). 824 western R. Co. v. (235 U. S. 350).

99 Adkins v. Arnold (235 U. S. 417).

118 Armour Fertilizer Works, Coe v. (237 U. A. J. Phillips Co. v. Grand Trunk Western S. 413)...

625 R. Co. (236 U. S. 662)...

444 Arnold, Adkins v. (235 U. S. 417). 118 Aktiesselskabet Ingrid v. Central R. Co. of Ashepoo Fertilizer Co. v. Townsend (238 New Jersey (238 U. S. 615). 284 U. S. 619)....

601 Alaska Gastineau Min. Co. v. Alaska Tread- Atcherley, Kapiolani Estate v. (238 U. S.

well Gold Min. Co. (238 U. S. 614)..... 283 119) Alaska Treadwell Gold Min. Co., Alaska Atchison, T. & S. F. R. Co., McCabe v. Gastineau Min. Co. v. (238 U. S. 614)... 283 (235 U. S. 151)...

69 Albert Lorsch & Co., United States v. (238 Atchison, T. & S. F. R. Co., Ritterbusch U. S. 637) 940 v. (235 U. S. 683)..

201 Albertucci, Monagas v. (235 U. S. 81). 95 Atchison, T. & S. F. R. Co. v. Vosburg (238 Alderson, State of Montana ex rel. General U. S. 56)...

675 Electric Co. v. (238 U. S. 644)

662 Atkins' Trustee, First Nat. Bank of PaduAlexander Bryant Co., United States for cah, Ky., v. (236 U. S. 288).

377 Use of, v. New York Steam Fitting Co. Atkins' Trustee v. Globe Bank & Trust Co. (235 U. S. 327)...

108 of Paducah, Ky. (236 U. S. 288)..... 377 Alexander Eccles & Co. v. Louisville & N. Atkins' Trustee, Old State Nat. Bank of R. Co. (238 U. S. 617).

417 Evansville, Ind., v. (236 U. S. 288).. 377 Alexander-Edgar Lumber Co., Knapp v. Atlantic Coast Lumber Corp. v. Minshew (237 U. S. 162) 515 (235 U. S. 685).

202 American Bonding Co. of Baltimore, Md., Aton Piano Co., Chicago, M. & St. P. R. v. Brown (238 M. S. 622)... 661 Co. v. (235 U. S. 715).

282 American Car & Foundry Co. v. Kettelhake Attorney General of State of West Virginia, (236 U. S. 311)....

355 Norfolk & W. R. Co. v. (236 U. S. 605).. 437 American Fruit Product Co., United Surety Attorney General, State of North Dakota Co. v. (238 U. S. 140)..

828 ex rel., Minneapolis, St. P. & S. S. M. R. American Publishers' Ass'n, Straus v. (235

Co. v. (236 U. S. 585)..

429 U. S. 716)..

197 Attorney General, State of North Dakota American Seeding Mach. Co. v. Common

ex rel., Northern Pac. R. Co. v. (236 U. wealth of Kentucky (236 U. S. 660)..... 456 S. 585)..

429 American Surety Co. of New York V. Automobile Supply Mfg. Co., Lovell-McSchultz (237 U. S. 159)...

525 Connell Mfg. Co. v. (235 U. S. 383).... 132 American Surety Co. of New York V. Shulz (237 U. S. 159).

525 Bache v. United States (235 U. S. 702). 207 American Water Softener Co. v. Lankford Backus, Cardonnel v. (235 U. S. 715).. 209 (235 U. S. 496).

184 Backus, Chan Kum v. (235 U. S. 714)..... 209 American Water Softener Co. v. State Backus, Chun Kim v. (238 U. S. 643). 661

Banking Board of State of Oklahoma Bacon, Iowa Cent. R. Co. v. (236 U. S. 305) 357 (235 U. S. 496)

184 Baltimore & 0. R. Co., Robinson v. (237 U. American Well Works Co. v. Layne & S. 84)...

491 Bowler Co. (238 U. S. 612).

937 Bankers' Surety Co. v. Elkhorn River |

v Amundson v. Folsom (238 U. S. 630). 793 Drainage Dist. (235 U. S. 702).

206 Anderson v. Chenault (235 U. S. 700). 201 Baron du Laurens d'Oiselay, People of

| Anderson v. Forty-Two Broadway Co. (235 Porto Rico v. (235 U. S. 251).

33 U. S. 699)....

200 Barrows, Finlayson v. (238 U. S. 640) 941 Anderson v. Hultberg (238 U. S. 605). 418 Bartlett, United States v. (235 U. S. 72 14 Anderson, Myers v. (238 U. S. 368).

932 Bauer, Caldwell v. (238 U. S. 607)... 602 Anderson, State Savings & Commercial Beals v. Burke (238 U. S. 634)..

938 Bank v. (238 U. S. 611).... 792 Beals v. Sleight (238 U. S. 625).

663 Anderson v. Swedish Evangelical Mission Behrman, Louisiana Ry. & Nav. Co. v. (235 Covenant (235 U. S. 692)...... 206 U. S. 164)...

62 Anderson v. Swedish Evangelical Mission Benner v. New York City Rys. Co. (238 Covenant (238 U. S. 605). . 418 U. S. 632)..

794 Arbuthnot v. Central Trust Co. of Illinois Bergdoll v. Harrigan (238 U. S. 609). 663 (238 U. S. 624).

662 Bernhard, Daniels v. (237 U. S. 572). 749 Arctic Lumber Co., Borden v. (235 U. S. Berwind-White Coal Min. Co. v. Chicago 704) 209 & E. R. Co. (235 U. S. 371)..

131 Arizona Copper Co. v. State of Arizona ex Bethune v. State of South Carolina (238 U. rel. Webster (238 U. S. 611).. 937 S. 646)..

.. 794 Arizona ex rel. Webster, Arizona Copper B. F. Sturtevant Co., Sirocco Engineering Co. v. (238 U. S. 611). 937 Co. v. (238 U. S. 636).

939 Arizona Mut. Savings & Loan Ass'n, Farm- Bingham County, Bothwell v. (237 U. S. ers' & Merchants' Bank v. (238 U. S. 628) 791 642)

702 Arizona & N. M. R. Co. v. Clark (235 U. S. Blagg, Jeffrey Mfg. Co. v. (235 U. S. 571) 167 669)

210) 35 S.C.

(vii)