COMPENSATION CASES

ANNOTATED

THE WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION, EMPLOYERS' LIABILITY
AND CURRENT NEGLIGENCE CASES DECIDED IN THE
FEDERAL COURTS OF THE UNITED STATES,
THE COURTS OF LAST RESORT OF ALL

THE STATES AND TERRITORIES

AND THE ENGLISH AND
CANADIAN COURTS

c+

COPYRIGHT 1922

BY
CALLAGHAN & COMPANY

FEB 3 1923

TABLE OF CASES
OF CASES REPORTED.

[In addition to the cases reported at length in this volume are numerous annotations which appear in the footnotes. These annotations consist of abstracts of cases giving statement of facts and excerpts from opinions. Cases appearing in the notes are designated by the letter n preceding the number of the page on which the same appear in this volume, as, for instance: Adams v. Hines,

Wash.

196 Pac. 19..

n28]

A

-Wash. -,

196 Pac. 19..

Adams v. Hines..

Adams v. New York, N. H. & H. R. Co..199 Mass. 476, 85 N. E. 585.
Adams Exp. Co. v. Allen..
.125 Va. 530, 100 S. E. 473..
Adams Exp. Co. v. White.
132 Md. 626, 104 Atl. 110..
178 Iowa 161, 159 N. W. 705..
Miss., 91 So. 4..

Akin v. Madison County.
Alabama & V. Ry. Co. v. Dennis.
Alameda County v. Tieslau.....
Alexander v. Al. G. Barnes Amusement

Cal. App., 186 Pac. 398.....

Co.

Alexander v. Great Northern R. Co.
Allen v. Dunham...

Allen v. Holler..

105 Wash. 346, 177 Pac. 786...
51 Mont. 565, 154 Pac. 914....
188 Mo. App. 193, 175 S. W. 135..
N. Y. App. Div. 192 N. Y.
Supp. 351..

5 Ohio App. 284...
Idaho -

Allen v. Smith.....
Allen-Wright Furniture Co. v. Hines...
Amalgamated Sugar Co. V. Industrial

Commission
Utah 189 Pac. 69..
American Car & Foundry Co. v. Adams..178 Ind. 607, 99 N. E. 993.
American Coal Min. Co. v. Crenshaw....
Ind. App. -
133 N. E. 394...
213 Fed. 185......

American Ice Co. v. Porreca.....
American Maize Products Co. v. Widiger. 186 Ind. 227, 114 N. E. 457.
Amiot v. Foster....

213 Mass. 573, 100 N. E. 1007....
Wash. -
200 Pac. 576..
220 Mass. 28, 107 N. E. 376..

-

iii

Anderson v. Bauer.

Anderson v. Boston El. R. Co.

Anderson v. Director General of Rail

roads

N. J. L. -
110 Atl. 829....
Mo. -
233 S. W. 203.

Anderson v. Kansas City Rys. Co......
Anderson v. Memphis St. Ry. Co.... 143 Tenn. 216, 227 S. W. 39..
Anderson v. Metropolitan St. R. Co....159 Mo. App. 449, 141 S. W. 461.
Anderson v. Michigan Cent. R. Co.. 168 Mich. 207, 132 N. W. 480....
Anderson v. Miller Scrap Iron Co.... Wis. 182 N. W. 852, aff'd
Wis. 187 N. W. 746........

200 Pac. 889...

n28

n589

223

n490

n100

n763

n162

n73

n611

n854

n273

n974

n292

n215

n928

n643 n939

n928

n741 n407 n845

n5 n724 n476

n849

n584

n412

Anderson v. Puget Sound Traction, Light

& Power Co..

.89 Wash. 83, 154 Pac. 135...... Anderson v. St. Louis & S. F. R. Co.... (Mo. App.), 184 S. W. 481.... Arens v. Baltimore & O. C. Terminal R.

Co.

213 Ill. App. 273.

Arkansas Cent. R. Co. v. Janson... .90 Ark. 494, 119 S. W. 648....
Arkansas Midland R. Co. v. Worden....90 Ark. 407, 119 S. W. 828..
Arkin v. Page.
.287 Ill. 420, 123 N. E. 30, rev'g 212
Ill. App. 282.

Armitage v. Chicago, M. & St. P. R. Co..54 Mont. 38, 166 Pac. 301.
Armstrong v. Chicago, M. & St. P. Ry. Co.35 S. D. 398, 152 N. W. 696.....
Arnold v. State..
.163 N. Y. App. Div. 253, 148 N. Y.
Supp. 479

.85 Ore. 333, 166 Pac. 29.

Askay v. Maloney...
Associated Employers' Reciprocal V.
State Industrial Commission.....
Associated Employers' Reciprocal V.
State Industrial Commission.....
Atchison, T. & S. F. Ry. Co. v. Smythe..55

Atchison, T. & S. F. Ry. Co. v. Sun
Drilling Co.
Okla. -1
165 Pac. 1133....
Atlanta Baggage & Cab Co. v. Mizo.. .4 Ga. App. 407, 61 S. E. 844..
Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Beazley. ...54 Fla. 311, 45 So. 761....
Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Harris....1 Ga. App. 667, 57 S. E. 1030...
Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Kelly....16 Ala. App. 360, 77 So. 972....
Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Kennedy..20 Ga. App. 238, 92 S. E. 973....
Atwell v. Winkler...
196 N. Y. App. Div. 946, 188 N. Y.
Supp. 158...

4 Ga. App. 113, 60 S. E. 1075...
Kan.
200 Pac. 293...
213 Mass. 589, 101 N. E. 78....

ད

....

Augusta Ry. & Elec. Co. v. Lyle.....
Austin v. American Ry. Exp. Co...
Ayers v. Ratshesky...

B

Okla. - 200 Pac. 174.......

Okla. -"
200 Pac. 862.......
Tex. Civ. App. 557, 119 S. W.
892

-;

Badie v. Columbia Brewing Co..... 142 La. 853, 77 So. 768....
Bailey v. Sovereign Camp, W. O. W... - Neb. 184 N. W. 920.....
Baillod v. Nelson Grain Co..
93 Kan. 775, 145 Pac. 895...
Baker v. Garce...
. (Tex. Civ. App.), 213 S. W. 299..
Baker v. New York, N. H. & H. R. Co.. 191 N. Y. App. Div. 322, 181 N. Y.
Supp. 675
Baker v. Southern Pac. Co..
Cal. -
193 Pac. 765.
Baldwin v. Omaha & C. B. St. R. Co....105 Neb. 614, 181 N. W. 525..
Baldwin v. Parsons..

Iowa - 186 N. W. 665...

10 Ala. App. 329, 65 So. 416.

Ballanger v. Shumate.

Baltimore Dry Docks & Shipbuilding Co.

v. Webster....

Baltimore & O. C. Terminal R. Co. v.

Becker Milling Mach. Co..... Baltimore & O. R. Co. v. Mangus... Baltimore & O. R. Co. v. Taylor...

Md. 116 Atl. 842......

272 Fed. 933.....

Ind. App. - 126 N. E. 863. 186 Fed. 828.

...

n448

n615

n762

n133

n603

n248

n773

n225

n899

n875

n653

n667

n493

n227

n496

n601

n484

n510

n778

n45 n842

n235

n220

n751

n406 n937 n770

n34 n9 n841 n246

n89

n636

n489

n806

n583

Bannigan v. Woodbury.

Baltimore & O. R. Co. v. White........176 Fed. 900...
Baltimore & O. S. W. R. Co. v. Burtch..- Ind. -
134 N. E. 858.....
.166 Mich. 491, 132 N. W. 77..
Bannigan v. Woodbury.
.158 Mich. 206, 122 N. W. 531.
Barber v. Louisiana Ry. & Nav. Co....141 La. 1059, 76 So. 199..
Barclay v. Puget Sound Lumber Co....48 Wash. 241, 93 Pac. 430.
Barker v. Dairymen's Milk Products Co. 205 Ala. 470, 88 So. 588..
Barnes v. Honey Grove Natatorium Co..(Tex. Civ. App.), 228 S. W. 354..
Barnes v. Providence Sanitarium..

(Tex. Civ. App.), 229 S. W. 588...
.213 Ill. App. 129....

Co..123 Minn. 153, 143 N. W. 263..
Utah -
189 Pac. 70....

Barnett v. Levy.....

Barnett v. Minneapolis & St. L. R.
Barry v. Los Angeles & S. L. R. Co..
Barshfield v. Vucklich..

Barton v. Craighill....

Barton V. Studebaker Corporation

Bauer v. Griess....
Baughman v. Metropolitan St. Ry.
Bay v. Merrill & Ring Logging

America

Basel v. Ansonia Clock Co....

Cal. App. -
189 Pac. 1025....
.216 N. Y. 356, 110 N. E. 767...
Basham v. Chicago Great Western R. Co. 178 Iowa 998, 154 N. W. 1019....
Baudassi v. Molla...
192 N. Y.

N. Y. App. Div.
Supp. 776

Neb. -, 181 N. W. 156..
Co..(Mo. App.), 177 S. W. 800.....
Co....243 U. S. 40, 61 L. Ed. 580, 37 Sup.
Ct. 376, aff'g 220 Fed. 295....
Minn.,
182 N. W. 607...

Beach v. Gendler...

Beall v. Kansas City Rys. Co..
Beard v. Davis.....

.108 Kan. 761, 197 Pac. 205..
.268 Pa. 464, 112 Atl. 96..

of

Bergeron v. Texas & P. R. Co...
Berges v. Guthrie...

n524

n682

n798

n271

208 S. W. 935.. n74

(Mo. App.), 228 S. W. 834..
..86 W. Va. 437, 103 S. E. 278.
Beaumont S. L. & W. Ry. Co. v. Myrick..- Tex. Civ. App.
Bell v. Brooklyn Union Gas Co........193 N. Y. App. Div. 669, 184 N. Y.
Supp. 807....

Bell v. Procter & Gamble Mfg. Co......152 N. Y. App. Div. 434, 137 N. Y.
Supp. 266...
.180 N. Y. Supp. 461.

Bender v. Dazian....
Benner v. Wallace Lumber & Manu-

facturing Co....

Bennett v. Page Bros..

.55 Wash. 579, 105 Pac. 145. . . . . .
197 N. Y. App. Div. 745, 189 N. Y.
Supp. 529

Berry v. Atlantic Ry.....

Berry v. M. F. Donovan & Sons.
Bethlehem Steel Co. v. Variety Iron &
Steel Co......

Biggs v. Peoria & P. U. Ry. Co...
Bilyeu v. Beck....
Birmingham Railway, Light & Power Co.
v. Camp.....

......

n117

n29

n809

n810

n613

n912

n68

n901

n310

n44

n179

n485

n963

n693

n51 n915

n597

Md.

-- "

115 Atl. 59... 182 Ill. App. 613....

.178 N. C. 481, 100 S. E. 891......

n640

n41

n852

n431

Benoit v. Boston & N. St. R. Co........216 Mass. 320, 103 N. E. 830.... n828 Benton v. Regeser.

Berg v. Michell...

.20 Ariz. 273, 179 Pac. 966...... n248 .196 Ill. App. 509..

n960

.144 La. 225, 80 So. 262.

n786

n966

Cal. App. -
197 Pac. 356....
.109 Me. 330, 84 Atl. 740.....
Me. -
115 Atl. 250.

n130

n865

n545

n940 n754

n933

n425

n580

n266

.2 Ala. App. 649, 57 So. 50...... n455