REPORTS OF CASES

HEARD AND DETERMINED IN THE

APPELLATE DIVISION

OF THE

SUPREME COURT

OF THE

STATE OF NEW YORK.

JEROME B. FISHER, REPORTER.

VOLUME CLXXII.

1916.

J. B. LYON COMPANY,

ALBANY, N. Y.

Entered, according to Act of Congress, in the year nineteen hundred and sixteen,

BY FRANCIS M. HUGO, SECRETARY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK,

In trust for the benefit of the People of the said State, in the office of the Librarian of Congress at Washington, D. C.

JAN 29 1917

J. B. LYON COMPANY,
PRINTERS, ELECTROTYPERS AND BINDERS,
LYON BLOCK, ALBANY, N. Y.

* Designated by the Governor to sit temporarily.

Designated to sit as Associate Justice in place of Hon. JAMES A. ROBSON, who died February 1, 1916.