THE

SOUTHWESTERN REPORTER

WITH KEY-NUMBER ANNOTATIONS

VOLUME 176

PERMANENT EDITION

CONTAINING ALL THE CURRENT DECISIONS OF THE

SUPREME AND APPELLATE COURTS OF

ARKANSAS, KENTUCKY, MISSOURI, TENNESSEE

AND TEXAS

WITH TABLE OF SOUTHWESTERN CASES IN WHICH

REHEARINGS HAVE BEEN DENIED

AND

TABLE OF WRITS OF ERROR DENIED, DISMISSED, OR GRANTED
BY THE SUPREME COURT OF TEXAS IN CASES IN

THE COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS

JUNE 2 — JUNE 30, 1915

KF
135

ST. PAUL
WEST PUBLISHING CO.

1915

COPYRIGHT, 1915

BY

WEST PUBLISHING COMPANY

(176 S.W.)

JUDGES

OF THE

COURTS REPORTED DURING THE PERIOD

COVERED BY THIS VOLUME

ARKANSAS-Supreme Court.
EDGAR A. McCULLOCH, CHIEF JUSTICE,

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
CARROLL D. WOOD,

WILLIAM F. KIRBY.
JESSE C. IIART.

FRANK SMITH.

KENTUCKY_Court of Appeals.

SIIACKELFORD MILLER, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
JOHN D. CARROLL.

J. B. JIANNAH.
W. E. SETTLE.

C. S. XCXX.
C. C. TURNER.

ROLLIN HURT.

COMMISSIONER OF APPEALS.
WILLIAM ROGERS CLAY.

MISSOURI—Supreme Court.
ARCHELAUS M. WOODSON, CHIEF JUSTICE.

Division No. 1.
W. W. GRAVES, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
ARCIELAUS M. WOODSON.

HENRY W. BOND,
JAMES T. BLAIR.

Dirision No. 2
CHAS. B. FARIS, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES,
JOIIN C. BROWN.

ROBERT F. WALKER.

SUPREME COURT COMMISSIONERS,
TOBERT T. RAILEY.

REUBEN F. ROY.
STELITEN S. BROWN.

FRED L. WILLIAMS.

The St. Louis Court of Appeals.
GEORGE D. REYNOLDS, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
ALBERT D. NORTONI.

WILLIAM II. ALLEN.

The Kansas City Court of Appeals.
JAMES ELLISON, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
J. M. JOHNSON.

FRANCIS II. TRIMBLE.

The Springfield Court of Appeals.
W. R. ROBERTSON, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
JOUX S. FARRINGTOX.

JOHN T. STURGIS.

(v)