ty. Keifer & Keifer, for plaintiff in error. Stafford & Arthur, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SUMMERS, C. J., and CREW, SPEAR, DAVIS, and PRICE, JJ., concur. DEVORE v. PITTSBURG, C., C. & ST. L. RY. CO. (No. 11,444.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 11, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Harrison County. Hollingsworth & Worley, for plaintiff in error. Dunbar & Sweeney and Albert O. Barnes, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed, on the ground that the plaintiff's evidence clearly raised a presumption of contributory negligence, which was not removed. SUMMERS, C. J., and SPEAR, DAVIS, and PRICE, JJ., concur. DIEHL v. HUFFMAN et al. (No. 11,136.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 18, 1910.) Er ror to Circuit Court, Clark County. George S. Dial and Bowman & Bowman, for plaintiff in error. Keifer & Keifer, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment reversed, and judgment for plaintiff in error, on authority of Railroad Co. v. Village of Roseville, 76 Ŏhio St. 108, 81 N. E. 178, and District of Columbia v. Robinson, 180 U. S. 92, 21 Sup. Ct. 283, 45 L. Ed. 440. SUMMERS, C. J., and CREW, DAVIS, and SHAUCK, JJ., concur. ELDRIDGE & HIGGINS CO. v. COURTRIGHT. (No. 11,583.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 15, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Franklin County. O. H. Mosier, for plaintiff in error. Charles M. Courtright, for defendant in FIRST NAT. BANK OF FINDLAY v. OVERHOLT et al., County Com'rs, et al. (No. 11,533.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 8, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Hancock County. J. A. & E. V. Bope, for plaintiff in error. W. L. David and Charles A. Blackford, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SUMMERS, C. J., and CREW and SHAUCK, JJ., concur. FIRST NAT. BANK OF UPPER SANDUS ror to Circuit Court, Hancock County. George PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. GLENN et al. v. EICHER et al. (No. 11,231.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 25, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Hamilton County. John J. Gasser, for plaintiffs in error. Closs & Leubbert and Jacob Krummel, for defendants in er ror. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SUMMERS, C. J., and DAVIS and PRICE, JJ., concur. KY v. PEOPLE'S SAVINGS BANKING CO. (No. 11.061.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Oct. 19, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court, Wyandot County. D. C. Parker and Carter & Goodrich, for plaintiff in error. Balyeat & Conn and Carey & Carey, for defendant in error. GRAY et al. v. ARB. (No. 11,024.) (Supreme PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. Court of Ohio. Sept. 28, 1909.) Error to CirSUMMERS, SPEAR, and SHAUCK, JJ., cuit Court, Columbia County. W. F. Lones, for plaintiffs in error. Wells & McDonald and Potts & Wells, for defendant in error. concur. FOLLETT v. CITY OF NEWARK. (No. 11.313.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 23, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court, Licking County. Charles H. Follett, for plaintiff in error. Frank A. Bolton, City Sol., and Flory & Flory, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. GRINER v. STATE. (No. 11,786.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Oct. 5, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court, Allen County. Becker & Recker, for plaintiff in error. B. F. Welty, CREW, C. J., and SUMMERS, DAVIS, Pros, Atty., and B. E. O'Connor, Asst. Pros. SHAUCK, and PRICE, JJ., concur. FOX v. FOX. (No. 11,443.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 11, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Hancock County. James P. Mourer and Jesse Stephens, for plaintiff in error. John D. Snyder and Hiram Van Campen, for defendant in error. Atty., for the State. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. HALL V. BATES et al. (No. 11,046.) (Su- | McBride, for plaintiff in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. cur. HALPIN v. SLOWAY. (No. 11,072.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 16, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court, Cuyahoga County. M. D. Herrick, J. C. Jones, and Ross Hedges, for plaintiff in error. Thomas L. Gifford, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. cur. HAMILTON v. FIRST NAT. BANK OF WELLSTON et al. (No. 11,539.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 15, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Jackson County. McGillivray & Armstrong, for plaintiff in error. Grosvenor, Jones & Worstell, Frank B. Finney, E. H. Willis, and T. S. Hogan, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SUMMERS, C. J., and CREW, SPEAR, DAVIS, and SHAUCK, JJ., concur. HAMMOND v. SUPREME RULING OF FRATERNAL MYSTIC CIRCLE et al. (No. 11,218.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 16, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court, Hancock County. Poe & Poe, for plaintiff in error. Mc Conica & Dwiggins, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. CREW, C. J., and SUMMERS, SPEAR, DAVIS, SHAUCK, and PRICE, JJ., concur. HANGEN v. LUTZ et al. (No. 11,397.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Dec. 14, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court, Darke County. Trainor & Trainor, for plaintiff in error. Robeson & Yount, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. concur. HARMON v. LIPPINCOTT. (No. 11,851.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 8, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Allen County. Edward Colston, Jay Leach, I. R. Longsworth, and Morrison R. Waite, for plaintiff in error. D. C. Henderson, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SUMMERS. C. J., and SPEAR, SHAUCK, and PRICE, JJ., concur. HASKELL v. COLUMBUS SAVINGS & HAUKE v. HAUKE. (No. 11.200.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 9, 1909.) Error Steele & Sams, PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. HAUPT v. HAZLETT. (No. 11,343.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 30, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court, Richland County. Bowers & Stephenson, for plaintiff in error. C. O. Sheller and A. A. Douglas, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. CREW, C. J., and SUMMERS, SPEAR, DAVIS, and SHAUCK, JJ., concur. HAYES v. HEYL et al. (No. 11,327.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 8, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Wayne County. A. D. Metz, for plaintiff in error. Mahlon Rouch and W. F. Kean, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed, on authority of Milliken v. Welliver, 37 Ohio St. 460. CREW, SPEAR, and SHAUCK, JJ., concur. HEIDLEBAUGH, Probate Judge, v. RECKER. (No. 11,632.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 9, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court, Putnam County. E. R. Eastman, Malone & Griffiths, W. B. Wheeler, and B. A. Unverferth, Pros. Atty., for plaintiff in error. Straman & Straman, Watts & Moore. Messrs. Henry & Robert Newbegin, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. The circuit court having erred in allowing a peremptory writ of mandamus, its judgment should not be affirmed. The contested election case having been effectively certified to the court of common pleas, a judgment of reversal would now be unavailing. The petition in error is therefore dismissed. SPEAR, DAVIS, SHAUCK, and PRICE, JJ., concur. HENDERSON v. PETER. (No. 11,462.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 11, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Holmes County. David T. Simpson, for plaintiff in error. Stilwell & Bailey, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SUMMERS, C. J., and SPEAR, DAVIS, SHAUCK, and PRICE, JJ., concur. HENSLEY v. FISCHER et al. (No. 11.294.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 23, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court, Lawrence County. Julius L. Anderson, L. K. Cooper, and Andrews & Irish, for plaintiff in error. A. R. Johnson and Hager & Stewart, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SUMMERS, SPEAR, DAVIS, SHAUCK, and PRICE, JJ., concur. HERMAN LININGER MFG. CO. v. FIRST NAT. BANK OF CRESTLINE. (No. 11,282.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Nov. 16, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court. Crawford County. Finley & Gallinger and Wickham & Feighner, for plaintiff in error. R. U. Miller, P. W. Poole, and R. V. Sears, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SUMMERS, DAVIS, and SIIAUCK, JJ., concur. HERNING v. STATE (No. 11.936.) (Su Circuit Court, Tuscarawas County. J. G. Pat-1 rick, for plaintiff in error. W. B. Stevens and W. H. Phillips, for the State. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. Schoenle, for plaintiff in error. W. A. Hicks and W. F. North, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment of the circuit court reversed, and judgment of the court of CREW, C. J., and SUMMERS, SPEAR, DA- common pleas affirmed, on authority of State VIS, and PRICE, JJ., concur. H. WETTER MFG. CO. v. KENTON BAKING POWDER CO. (No. 11,054.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Dec. 23, 1909.) Error to Superior Court of Cincinnati. Harmon, Colston, Goldsmith & Hoadly, for plaintiff in error. C. B. Matthews and Joseph W. O'Hara, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment reversed, and judgment of superior court in special term affirmed. CREW, C. J., and SUMMERS, SPEAR, and PRICE, JJ., concur. INCORPORATED VILLAGE OF MADISONVILLE v. SAUER et al. (No. 11,390.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 18, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Hamilton County. H. W. Vordenberg, Louis A. Ireton, and Walter M. of Ohio v. Carter, 67 Ohio St. 422, 66 N. E. 537. SUMMERS, C. J., and CREW, DAVIS, SHAUCK, and PRICE, JJ., concur. Harwitz, for plaintiff in error. J. S. Forgy, for defendant in error. remanded to the court of common pleas for a PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SUMMERS, C. J., and DAVIS, SHAUCK, cur. ney, for plaintiff in error. Toland & Pearson, Ex parte KUCHTA. (No. 11,893.) (Supreme J. S. McCONNELL WOOL CO. v. SWET-cuit Court, Cuyahoga County. Myler & TurCourt of Ohio. Oct. 26, 1909.) Error to CirLAND. (No. 11,342.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 15, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court Knox County. Waight & Moore and Jenner & Weldon, for plaintiff in error. Owen & Carr and L. C. Stillwell, for defendant in error PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. KEHM v. GERMAN MUT. INS. CO. OF CINCINNATI. (No. 11,326.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 8, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Hamilton County. Albert Bettinger, for plaintiff in error. John Sayler and Sayler & Sayler, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. KESLAR v. BARNARD & KEARNS. (No. 11,525.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 8, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Wood County. Troup & Riegle and Blackford & Blackford, for plaintiff in error. N. R. Harrington, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. SUMMERS, C. J., and CREW, SPEAR, DAVIS, and PRICE, JJ., concur. KING et al. v. SMITH. (No. 11,386.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Dec. 14, 1909.) Error to Circuit Court, Perry County. M. A. Daugherty, for plaintiffs in error. John Ferguson and Owen Yost, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. CREW, C. J., and SPEAR, DAVIS, SHAUCK, and PRICE, JJ., concur. KLINEK et al. v. MAGUIRE. (No. 11,570.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Jan. 11, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Hamilton County. Franklin T. Cahill, for plaintiffs in error. Healy, Ferris & McAvoy, for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment affirmed. CREW, SPEAR, and SHAUCK, JJ., concur. KLING et al. v. JAMISON et al. (No. 11,197.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 1, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court. Darke County. Robeson & Yount and Fitzgerald & Sprigg, for plaintiffs in error. Martz & Hughes and George W. Mannix, Jr., for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment reversed, and cause remanded for new trial. Grounds stated in journal entry. It is ordered and adjudged by this court that the judgment of the said circuit court be, and the same hereby is, reversed for error in not reversing the judgment of the court of common pleas for error in overruling the motion for a new trial on the ground that that court erred in receiving the verdict and discharging the jury without requiring the jury to answer the tenth interrogatory; and, this court proceeding to render the judgment that said circuit court should have rendered, it is ordered and adjudged that the judgment of the court of common pleas be, and the same is hereby, reversed for error in overruling the motion for a new trial on the ground that that court erred in receiving the verdict and discharging the jury without requiring the jury to for defendant in error. PER CURIAM. Judgment reversed, and court of common pleas affirmed, on authority of McGorray v. Murphy, 80 Ohio St. 413, 88 N. E. 881. CREW, C. J., and SUMMERS, SPEAR, DAVIS, and SHAUCK, JJ., concur. LAKE ERIE & W. R. CO. v. GOOD et al. (No. 11,507.) (Supreme Court of Ohio. Feb. 1, 1910.) Error to Circuit Court, Mercer County. John B. Cockrum, Walter B. Richie, and John W. Loree, for plaintiff in error. Ford & Raudabaugh, for defendants in error. PER CURIAM. On petition in error, judgment affirmed. CREW, SPEAR, and PRICE, JJ., concur. On cross-petition in error, judgment against cross-petitioner reversed as per journal entry. SUMMERS, C. J., and DAVIS. SHAUCK, and PRICE, JJ., concur. It is ordered and adjudged by this court that the judgment of said circuit court be, and the same is hereby, affirmed as to the plaintiff in error, the Lake Erie & Western Railroad Company, is reversed, and the petition dismissed as to the and on the cross-petition in error the judgment Cross-petitioner in, error, Reuben HickockCREW, SPEAR, and PRICE, JJ., being of the opinion that the judgment as to the railroad company should be affirmed; SUMMERS, C. J., and DAVIS and SHAUCK, JJ., being of the opinion that upon the undisputed evidence the negligence of the decedent, Arminda Good, contributed as a proximate cause to her death; and PRICE, J., being of the opinion that a cause of action was not proven against the defendant Hickock. LECKLIDER v. JARRETT. (No. 11,114.) |