CONTENTS.

VOLUME I.

MESSAGE AND REPORT.

Message of the President transmitting report of commission to Congress.

Letter of transmittal....

Report of the commission...

Appendix A to report of the commission, "Memorandum showing the law

and conditions in the United States, Germany, and England," prepared by

Mr. Packer, secretary of the commission..............

Appendix B to report of the commission, proposed bill recommended by the

Page.

5-8

9

11-75

76-106

107-126

127-211

213

VOLUME II.

HEARINGS, BRIEFS, INDEX.

Table of cases.

V-XVI

Hearings held at Washington, D. C., May 10, 1911..

1-32

Hearings held at Washington, D. C., June 14-16, 1911 (Vol. I of S. Doc. 90, 62d

Cong., 1st sess..

33-230

Briefs submitted at Washington, D. C., June 14-16, 1911 (Vol. II of S. Doc. 90,

62d Cong., 1st sess., and appendix)..

231-544

Hearings held at Chicago, Ill., October 16, 17, 1911 (part 2).

Hearings held at Washington, D. C., November 6-10, 1911 (part 3)..

Hearings held at Washington, D. C., December 14-20, 1911 (part 4)..

General index of report, hearings, and appendices .

545-769

770-1114

1115-1474

1475

III

Addyston Pipe & Steel Co. v. United States (175 U. S., 211).

427 304, 474

Aetna Fire Insurance Co. v. Jones (59 S. E., 148; 13 L. R. A. (N. S.) 1147).. 357, 415, 713

Allen v. Pioneer Press (40 Minn., 117)..

Almy z. California (21 How., 169).

Allgever v. Louisiana (165 U. S., 578).

Anderson r. Baird (5 F., 972)..

Andrew. Failsworth Industrial Society (Eng.)

Antelope, The (10 Wheat., 66)..

266

382

309, 702, 1449

1411

1096

499, 501

Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Co. v. Riverside Mills (219 U. S., 186).

Assaria State Bank v. Dolley (219 U. S., 121)............. 246, 397, 403, 432, 471, 542, 543, 747 Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Railway Co. v. Matthews (175 U. S., 96).... (37), (106), 197, 204, 240, 402, 406, 696

r. Sowers (213 U. S., 55).

Atkins . Kansas (191 U. S., 207).

Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Co. v. North Carolina Corporation Commission (206 U. S., 1)....

(52)

430, 432, 467

627

(29), (49),

179, 203, 390, 405, 470, 471, 474

r. Wharton (207 U. S., 328).

Austin v. Tennessee (179 U. S., 343).

390, 482

1444

426

Bell's Gap Railroad v. Pennsylvania (134 U. S., 237).

Bertholf r. O'Reilly (74 N. Y., 509).

Austin v. Wilson (4 Cush., 273).

B.

Bacon t. Walker (204 U. S., 311)...

Ball r. Nye (99 Mass., 582).
Ballard v. Oil Co. (81 Miss., 507).

246, 297, 359, 698, 748

Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Co. v. Interstate Commerce Commission (221 U. S.,

612)..

r. Baugh (149 U. S., 368)..

426

1455

(27), (29)

Baltimore & Ohio & South Western Railroad Co. v. United States (220 U. S.,

Barnett. Atlantic & Pacific Railway Co. (68 Mo., 56; 30 Am. Rep., 773).
Bates r. Davies' Executors (West Bromwich County Court).

Beardsley v. New York, Lake Erie & Western Railroad Co. (162 N. Y., 230).

Beer Co. t. Massachusetts (97 U. S., 25). .

Bedford Quarries v. Bough (168 Ind., 675, 687).

Bennett . Scutt (18 Barb., 347).

(84)

250, 468 304, 434, 627

84, 292, 532, 1444

639

575

538

424

1445, 1455, 1457

1459

542

Bowman . Chicago & North Western Railway Co. (125 U. S., 482).

383

192, 248, 399,

639

Boyd r. United States (116 U. S., 616).

163

Braceville Coal Co. v. People (147 Ill., 315)..

345

Bradbury v. Chicago, Rock Island, and Pacific Railway Co. (Iowa) (128 N. W., 1) 1403

V

Bradfield v. Roberts (175 U. S., 291)..

Brad Glycerin Co. v. St. May Manufacturing Co. (60 U. S., 560).
Brice v. Edward Lloyd (Ltd.) (Court of App., Eng.)...

Brimmer, jr., v. Redman (138 U. S., 78)...

Brinkmeier v. Missouri Pacific Railway Co. (105 Pac., 221)...

Brintons (Ltd.) v. Turvey (Times Law Rep., 444 (1905), A. C., 320).

Broadhead v. Milwaukee (19 Wis., 624)..

Bronson v. Kinzie (1 How., 311).

Brown v. Houston (114 U. S., 630).

v. Kendall (6 Cush., 272).

v. New Jersey (175 U. S., 172).

Buckley v. Brown (Fed. Cas., No. 2092)..

Burkman v. Jamieson (25 Wash., 606; 66 Pac., 48).

Butler v. Frazee (211 U. S., 459)..

Buttfield v. Stranahan (192 U. S., 470).

C.

Cahill v. Eastman (18 Minn., 324).

Calkins v. Barger (44 Barb., 424).

Camden v. Allen (2 Dutch., 398).

Page.

97, 302

239

570

347

501

1095, 1406

354

476

383

234, 235, 236, 237, 238

429

696

696

465

423, 480

239

542

356

Camfield v. United States (167 U. S., 518).. 84, 246, 292, 310, 359, 432, 475, 544, 699, 748 Cammel, Laird & Co. (Ltd.) v. Platt (Court of Appeal, Eng.).

Casey v. St. Louis Transit Co. (116 Mo. App., 235; 91 S. W., 419).
Caspar v. Lewin (109 Pac., 667)..

Champion v. Ames (see Lottery case).

481

638, 639

463

696

575

Chapman v. Atlantic & St. Lawrence Railroad Co. (37 Me., 92)..
Charing Cross, Euston & Hampstead Ry. Co. v. Boots (Ct. of App., Eng.).
Charlotte, Columbia & Augusta Railroad Co. v. Gibbes (27 S. C., 385; 142 U. S.,
386)...

Chatham Furnace Co. v. Moffatt (147 Mass., 403).

295, 359, 364, 475, 700, 748

427

84, 292 (48),

Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad Co. v. Illinois (200 U. S., 561). Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad Co. v. McGuire (219 U.S., 549). 205, 207, 214, 406, 407, 423, 426, 431, 432, 446, 1111 v. United States (220 U. S., 559). Chicago, Kalamazoo & Western Railroad Co. v. Pontius (157 U. S., 209). Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railroad v. Ross (112 U. S., 377). v. Weston (178 Fed., 619)....

250, 475

431, 531

(78), (79)

1458

254

Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Co. v. Stahley (62 Fed., 363; 163 U. S., 680)... Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Co. v. Zernecke (183 U. S., 582). (46), 37, 38, 192, 196, 211, 241, 242, 248, 251, 260, 309, 337. 399, 403, 431, 444, 445, 540, 544, 632, 697, 1447, 1448 Chicago & St. Louis Railroad Co. v. Warrington (92 Ill., 157). Childress v. Southwest Missouri Railroad Co. (141 Mo. App., 667; 126 S. W., 169) Chin Bak Kan v. United States (186 U. S., 193). Citizens Savings & Loan Association v. Topeka (20 Wall., 655).

City of Alexandria, The (17 Fed., 399).

City of Newton v. Atchison (31 Kan., 151; 1 Pac., 288; 47 Am. Rep., 486).
Civil rights cases (109 U. S., 3).

Clayton & Shuttleworth v. Dobbs (Lincoln County Court)..
Cleveland, C. & S. L. R. v. Foland (Ind., April, 1910).

Clover, Clayton & Co. v. Hughes (1910, A. C., 242, 244)..
Clyatt v. United States (197 U. S., 207)..

Coggs v. Bernard (2 Ld. Raym., 909; S. L. C.).

Colasurdo v. Central Railroad of New Jersey (Fed. Rep.).
Cole v. Hall (103 Ill., 30).....

Colon v. Lisk (153 N. Y., 188).

Commonwealth v. Alger (7 Cush., 85).

r. Danziger (176 Mass., 290)..

r. Hamilton Manufacturing Co. (120 Mass., 383).

r. Huntley (156 Mass., 236).

r. Interstate Railway Co. (187 Mass., 436).

r. Intoxicating liquors (115 Mass., 153). r. Nutting (175 Mass., 154).

r. Pear (183 Mass., 242).. r. Perry (155 Mass., 117)... r. Sisson (189 Mass., 247). r. Strauss (191 Mass., 545).. r. Wheeler (205 Mass., 384). r. Williams (6 Gray, 1).. Connolly r. Union Sewer Pipe Co. Consolidated Coal Co. v. Illinois. Converse, In re (137 U. S., 624)..

(184 U. S., 540).

(See St. Louis, C. C. Co.)

Cooley v. Port Wardens (12 How., 299).

Coppe. Henninger (55 N. H., 179).

Cottrell v. Union Pacific Railroad Co. (2 Wyo., 540).

Page. 536, 538

84, 240, 292, 423, 536

Covington & Cincinnati Bridge Co. v. Kentucky (154 U. S., 204).
Covington & Lexington Turnpike Co. v. Kentucky (164 U. S., 578).

Crandall . Nevada (6 Wall., 35).

Craske v. Wegan (100 Law Times Rep., 8 (1909).

Crowley v. Christensen (137 U. S., 86).

Crutcher 2. Kentucky (141 U. S., 47)...

Cunningham v. Northwestern Improvement Co. (119 Pac., 554)..

D.

Dacres v. Oregon Railroad & Navigation Co. (1 Wash., 525)...

Danby Bank v. State Treasurer (39 Vt., 92). (See Receiver of Danby Bank.)

Dartmouth College v. Woodward (4 Wheat., 518).

Davidson v. New Orleans (96 U. S., 97)..

Davis v. Mills (194 U. S., 451).

T. Sawyer (133 Mass., 289).

Davis-Smith Co. v. Clausen.

Deal r. Mississippi County (107 Mo., 464)..

(See State ex rel.)

Debs, In re (158 U. S., 564)...

Delíel v. Hanson (2 Wash., 194; 26 Pac., 220).

640

535, 629

(30), 375, 487, 488, 702

Den v. Hoboken Land & Imp. Co. (See Murray v. H. L. & I. Co.)

Deppe v. Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Co. (36 Iowa, 52).

(53)

426

86,293

(27), (29), 385, 483, 485, 498

696

1457

357, 415

425

1449

236

236

(78)

319

94, 299

535 1400, 1401

East Kingston v. Towle (48 N. H., 57)..
Edwards v. Godfrey (1899) (2 K. B., 333).

E.

Edye r. Robertson (Head Money cases) (112 U. S., 580).

532 1409

91, 97, 297, 301

(33)

573

(27)

243,

253, 264, 432, 1362, 1402

Eilenbecker v. District Court of Plymouth County (134 U. S., 31). Ellis. The Lochgelly Iron & Coal Co. (Court of Session, Scotland) t. United States (206 U. S., 246)..

El Paso & Northeastern Railroad Co. v. Guiterrez (215 U. S., 87)..

Emerson v. Gardiner (8 Kans., 452).

696

Employer's Liability Cases (207 U. S., 463)..... (29), 34, 50, 161, 177, 203, 242, 244, 252, 254. 264, 379, 388, 389, 405, 432, 451, 474, 483, 490, 501, 627, 768, 1021, 1402, 1403, 1441 Engel r. O'Malley (219 U. S., 128).

542