THE
SOUTHWESTERN REPORTER

WITH KEY-NUMBER ANNOTATIONS

VOLUME 127
PERMANENT EDITION

CONTAINING ALL THE CURRENT DECISIONS OF THE

SUPREME AND APPELLATE COURTS OF

ARKANSAS, KENTUCKY, MISSOURI, TENNESSEE

AND TEXAS

WITH TABLE OF SOUTHWESTERN CASES IN WHICH
REHEARINGS HAVE BEEN DENIED

AND
TABLE OF STATUTES CONSTRUED

MAY 11—JUNE 1, 1910

ST. PAUL
WEST PUBLISHING CO.

COPYRIGHT, 1910

BY

WEST PUBLISHING COMPANY

(127 S.W.)

JUDGES

OF THE

COURTS REPORTED DURING THE PERIOD

COVERED BY THIS VOLUME

ARKANSAS–Supreme Court.
EDGAR A. McCULLOCH, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
BURRIIL B. BATTLE.

JESSE C. HART.
CARROLL D. WOOD.

SAMUEL FRAUENTHAL

KENTUCKY-Court of Appeals.

HENRY S. BARKER, CHIEF JUSTICE. 1
T. J. NUNX, CHIEF JUSTICE.2

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
HENRY S. BARKER. 1

JOHN D. CARROLL.
JOHN M. LASSING.

ED. C. O'REAR.
J. P. HOBSON.

W. E. SETTLE.
T. J. NUNN.2

COMMISSIONER OF APPEALS.
WILLIAM ROGERS CLAY.

MISSOURI-Supreme Court.
LEROY B. VALLIANT, CHIEF JUSTICE.

Division No. 1.
HENRY LAMM, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
WALLER W. GRAVES.

ARCHELAUS M. WOODSON.
LEROY B. VALLIANT.

Division No. 2.
JAMES B. GANTT, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
GAVON D. BURGESS.

JAMES D. FOX.

The Kansas City Court of Appeals.
E. J. BROADDUS, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
JAMES ELLISON.

J. M. JOHNSON.

The St. Louis Court of Appeals.
GEORGE D. REYNOLDS, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
RICHARD L. GOODE.

ALBERT D. NORTONI.

The Springfield Court of Appeals.
J. P. NIXON, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
ARGUS COX.

HOWARD GRAY.

? Became Chief Justice April 11, 1910.

? Became Associate Justice April 23, 1910.

TENNESSEE—Supreme Court.
W. D. BEARD, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
W. K. MCALISTER.

M. M. NEIL. JOHN K. SHIELDS.

BENNETT D. BELL.

TEXAS-Supreme Court.
REUBEN R. GAINES, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
THOMAS J. BROWN.

F. A. WILLIAJIS.

Court of Criminal Appeals.
W. L. DAVIDSON, PRESIDING JUDGE.

JUDGES.
W. F. RAMSEY.

F. J. McCORD.

Courts of Civil Appeals.

First District.
R. A. PLEASANTS, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
T. S. REESE.

S. A. MOMEANS.
Second District.
T. H. CONNER, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
OCIE SPEER.

IRBY DUNKLIN.
Third District.
W. M. KEY, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
B. H. RICE.

C. H. JENKINS.
Fourth District.
J. H. JAMES, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
W. S. FLY.

H. H. NEILL
Fifth District.
ANSON RAINEY, CHIEF JUSTICE..

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
JOHN BOOKHOUT.

J. M. TALBOT.
Sixth District.
SAMUEL P. WILLSON, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
RICHARD B. LEVY.

WM. HODGES.

74

Pante this sheet on the inside of the FRONT cover of vol. 127 S. w.a

State Report Citation of Cases in the SOUTHWESTERN REPORTER, VOL. 127. Tbe left-band column sbows the page of lbis volume on which a case begins, against which are shown the volume and page of the State Report where same case is to be found.

Illustration: The case of Barger v. Beach, is in S. W. Rep., vol. 127, p. 120. It can be cited as from the State Eeport by giving the citation opposite "120" (Reporter page column) in this table, i. e., "142 Mo. A. 389.”

Repr.

302.

962...

305.

TeX.

318

2

Су

Cy.

797...

Cy.

987

991....

Cy

309

199

R

Repr.

Repr.
Repr.

Repr. Page State Report Page State Report Page State Report Page State Report Page State Report .227 Mo. 45

.Tex. Cv. A. I 562 ... Tex. Cv. A. 782. ....138 Ky. 230 961. ..94 Ark. 570 226 Mo. 3

3022
... Tex. Cy. A. 564

.Tex.

785.....
...138. Ky. 23

..94 Ark. 566
Mo. 1
..227 MO. 61 666

Cv. 789..... 138 Ky. 251 963.... .94 Ark. 533
Mo. 307
.....227 Mo. 6 5671. ... Tex.

790
.............K y .

966.... .94 Ark. 578 227 Mo. | 332.... .227 Mo. 471 567** ....Tex.

791. ......138 Ky. 255

.94 Ark. 583 | 378.......147 Mo.

568* .... Tex.

792
......Ky. 1 9711....

....

.94 Ark. 621 Mo. 383.......112 Mo.

569 .....Tex.

794

..... Ky. 972.... .94 Ark. 560 7 Mo. 384.......142 Mo.

570 ....... Tex Су

795

.......Ky. 973.... .94 Ark. 558 27 Mo. 7 Mo, A. 619 572 .....lex.

103 Tex. 349 974.... .94 Ark. 499 927 Mo. 143 Mo. A. 258574 ..... Tex. Cv.

798....

....103 Tex. 357 | 975.... 94 Ark. 461 226 Mo. 994..... ...112 Mo. 577 .... ex.

799.........103 Tex. 359

1983.....

.94 Ark. 688 227 Mo. 397.... ..117 Mo. 680 .... Tex. Cv. 804.........103 Tex. 344 986•

.............K Y . .227 Mo. 1 399.......142 Mo.

581
.... Tex. Cv. A 806.........103 Tex. 354

......Ky.
.227 M
400.......143 No.

584* .... Tex. Cy., 808...58 Tex. Cr. A. 988.. .....138 Ky. 257 ....140 Mo. 406.......112 Mo. 587* .....Tex. Cv 8151..58 Tex. O

....138 Ky. 267 .....140 Mo. 408.......J17 Mo. 591 ....... Tex. 8152..58 Tex. C

993.

138 Ky. 271 930....140 Mo. 40.......117 Mo. A 67 593.......143 Mo. 326 8153..58 Tex. C

994

..Ky ......142 Mo.

13.......142 Mo,
5951......143 Mo. A. 499 8171..58 Tex. Cr.

R. 394 995. .. ......142 Mo. 510 415.......147 Mo. A 6952......143 Mo. A. 393 8172..58 Tex. C r. R. 393 997...... ..138 Ky. 277 ......142 Mo. 469

| 418.......147 Mo. A 598.......143 Mo. A. 200 817..59 Tex. Cr. R. 179 1000.........138 Ky. 287 .....143 Mo. 421.......148 Mo. A 602.......143 Mo. A. 226 819...59 Tex. O R. 177

..138 Ky. 302 .....143 MO. 318 425.......143 Mo. A 603.......113 Mo. A. 176 820...59 Tex. O r. R. 161 10071

.........Ky. ......142 Mo. 476 | 426.......147 Mo. A. 692 | 605.......143 Mo. 1..371 823...59 Tex. C

10072 109......142 Mo. 412 429.......148 Mo. 607.......143 Mo. A. 163 825...59 Tex. O

10081.

Ky. 309 ......142 Mo. 395 434.......148 Mo. 611.......143 Mo. A. 212 827...59 Tex. C

10082

.......Ky 11......142 Mo. 513 .117 Mo. A. 700 | 614.......148 Mo. A. 164 832...59 Tex. Cr. R. 141 1009

....Ky. 113......142 Mo.

.199 Tenn. 698 | 616.......113 Mo. A. 422 833...59 Tex. Cr. R. 157 1010.........138 Ky. 313 114......142 Mo. 446... .19? Tenn. 634 6181......1-18 Mo. A. 53 834...59 Tex. R. 146

1013.........138 Ky. 323 S......14: Mo. ...94 Ark. 375 618%......143 Mo. A. 524 835...59 Tex. R. 156

1014.........138 Ky. 326 ......142 Mo. 389 450.... ..94 Ark. 405 620.......148 Mo. A. 145 835..59 Tex. R. 147 1017 . ...........Ky. Mo. A. 4511... ...94 Ark. 378 623.......148 Mo. A. 173 836...59 Tex. C

2018.... ....102 Tex. 104 194......143 Mio. A. 519 4512... ..94 Ark. 414 | 625 ...143 Mo.

837. ....... Tex

10204.59 Tex. Cr. R. 119 194......12 MO. A. 373 453.... .91 Ark. 387 626.......148 Mo. A. 157 838

10202.59 Tex. Cr. R. 186 9 Tenn. 704

454...
94 Ark. 422 628.......143 Mo, A. 528

1025..59 Tex, Cr. R. 196 10... 137 Ky. 769 456..........94 Ark. 3 630.......148 Mo. A. 57 844 .......Tex,

Cy

1030..59 Tex. ur. R. 159 137 Ky. 773 94 Ark. 419 635.......148 Mo.

847 ....... Tex.

1031..59 Tex. Cr. R. 140 ....Ky. 459.... .94 Ark. 379 641.......143 Mo. 333 849• ....... Tex. Cv

1032..59 Tex.

131 Ky .94 Ark. 358 645.......148 Mo.

851

.....Tex. Cv. | 1035..59 Tex. C R. 260 Ky. 779 94 Ark. 407 649.......148 Mo.

85410 ...Tex. Cv. ? | 1037..59 Tex. C R. 162 .....137 Ky. 784 467... .94 Ark. 384 651. ..148 Mo. A. 33

8542

Cv. A. 1038..59 Tex. R. 149 ......137 Kv. 796 469 Ark. 380 656. .148 Mo. A. 216

Cy. A 1040..58 Tex. R. 360 .....137 Ky. 802 471....

137 Ky. 818
660.......148 Mo. A. 117 860 .......Tex. Cy

1053..59 Tex. O 252
....137 Ky. 811 472.... ......137 K
666.......143 Mo. A. 518 866 ....... Tex. C

1055..09 Tex.
Ky. 760 473*
............ K y 668.......148 Mo. A. 169

869 •

....... Tex. Cv. 1056..59 Tex.
..KY. 1 474.... ....137 Ky. 897 669.......143 Mo.

03.......143 MO, A. 402 872 ....... Tex. Cv. A. | 1058..59 Tex. Cu
..Ky 475. ......137 Ky. 831 672. ....143 Mo, A. 474 873 .....Tex, Cv. A 1060..59 Tex,
.....Ky. 476...... ....137 Ky. 834 678. ...148 Mo. A. 69

876 ....Tex. Cv. A. 106) ...... Tex. Cr. R. .....103 Tex. 304 477

680. .143 Mo. A. 459 1 879 .... Tex. Cv. A. 1062 ...... Tex. Cv. A. $49........103 Tex. 339 4781.

..Ky. 685.......148 Mo. A. 193

..... Tex. Cy 1064*

...... Tex. Cv. A. ........103 Tex. 336 4789

692. .143 Mo. A, 441

.......Tex. Cv 1066* ...... Tex. Cv. A. ........103 Te 329 ....... Ky. 698........122 Tenn. 73

....... Tex. Cv. 1068* ...... Tex. Cv, A. 72...59 Tex Cr. R. 82 480.

.137
701........122 Tenn. 656
884 ...... Tex. Ci

.... Tex. Cy. A.. 3...59 Tex. Cr. I 123 481. .....137 Ky. 841 7041.........94 Ark. 621

.....Tex. C

.... Tex. Cv. A. 173...59 1 ex. Cr.

483
2...
37 Ky. 845 705. ...94 Ark. 503

.... Tex. Cv

10761 ..... Tex. Cy. A. 3..59 Tex. C

90
485
.138
7061 ..94 Ark. 490

....Tex. Cv 10762* ..... Tex. Cv. A. *50...58 Tex. | 485..........139 Ky. 7 7067. .94 Ark. 451

891?•
....Tex, Cv

1077* ...... Tex. Cv. A. 10...58 Tex. 489..........138 Ky. ] 707 .94 Ark. 489 893

1079 ...... Tex. Cv. A. 189...58 Tex. C 621 1490..........138 Ky. 18708....

Ark. 433

895
.......Te.

1080 ...... Tex. Cv. A. Si...58 Tex. C

492•
...... Ky. 1710.....

.94 Ark. 426

896 .......Tex, Cv. 1083 ...... Tex. Cy. A. 23...58 Tez. C 611 . :3 ...... Ky. 711.

.94 Ark. 430

....... Tex. Cv 1087 ...... Tex. Cy. A. 9...59 Ter. C

117 494..
138 Ky. 25 713..... .94 Ark. 394

......Tex. Cv 1090 ......Tex. Cv. A. Wi...58 Te 624 496

715.

94 Ark. 524 8982 .... Tex. Cv. 1093 ......Tex. Cv. A. 94...58 Ter.

608 498..........138 Ky. 34
498....

718.

.94 Ark. 519 .......Tex. Cy. 1098* ......Tex. Cv. A ...58 Ter. C

617 500*
............... Ky.

720.... ..94 Ark. 443 901 ....... Tex. CY | 1101* ...... Tex. Cy. A **...58 Te 646 501 ..........138 Ky. 42 722 ..94 Ark. 448 902 .....Tex. Cv.

11091.

....... Tex. Cv. A. 2...58 Tex. C

209 503
...........K
23.... .94 Ark. 511

.... Tex. Cv. A. 11092 .....Tev. Cy. A ...58 Tex. C

505....
.138 Ky. 48

25..... .94 Ark. 505 905 ..... Tex. Cv. A. 11099* ..... Tex. Cv. A. ...59 Tex. C

506.... .138 Ky. 53 727+.........94 Ark. 621 907 ..... Tex. Cv. A. | 1114 ...... Tex. Cv. A. 23...59 TEX C

508.
.........A K

730.
.94 Ark. 530

....... Tex. Cv. A. 1117 ......Tex. Cy. A. 59 Tex. Cr.

511.
......Ky.

.94 Ark. 478

930* .

..... Tex. Cv. A. 1118* ......Tex. Cv, A. 512... 28 Ky.

.94 Ark. 514 913.......143 Mo. A. 502 1 1121* ...... Tex. Cv. A. .137 K;. 39

733.........
.94 Ark. 458
148 Mo. A. 52

... Tex. Cv. A. 516..... 138 Ky. 71

.94 Ark. 485 9182......144 Mo. A. 294 1126 ....Tex. Cv. A 519. 739. ..94 Ark. 453 9211......144 Mo. A. 1128

.Tex. Cv. A. ...Te

520

.......Ky. 1 740..........94 Ark. 438 921?......143 Mo. A. 675 1137 ...... Tex. Cv. A. Tex 523... .138 Ky. 82 743..........94 Ark. 400 922.......143 Mo.

1148* ...... Tex. Cv. A. ...Tex

.138 Ky. 98 745....
.94 Ark. 343 924.......143 Mo.

1152* ......Tex. Cv, A. 529... .138 Ky. 104 7467... 94 Ark. 621 9231......143 Mo.

11531 .....Tex, Cy. A. 531.... .138 Ky. 109 1747* .

....Ky. 9252 .148 Mo. A. 96 11532 .....Tex. Cv. A. 533... .)38 Ky. 116 6 748..... .138 Ky. 133 932.......143 Mo. A. 657 1155 ..... Tex. Cy. A .138 Ky. 120 7491

138 Ky. 137 9331......144 Mo. A 216 1156 ...... Tex. Cv. A. 5371

...... Ky. | 7492.........138 Ky. 138 933?......144 Mo, A 326 1160* ......Tex. Cv. A. 5372...

753
..... Ky. 934.......143 Mo. A

6981162

......Tex. Cv. A. ..Tez

538

........ Ky. 1754..... 138 Ky. 149 936.......143 Mo. 659 | 1164 ......Tex. Cv. A. ter

539....
.........103 Tex, 320

757*
...Ky 941.......144 Mo. A

315 1166

...Tex. Cv. A. 542...59 Tex. Cr. R. 3 758...

7. 157 9451......144 Mo. 348 1174

.Tex, Cy. A ..... Tex. 543...59 Tex. Cr. R

....Ky. 945°......144 Mo. A. 345 | 1178 ...Tex. Cy. A. ...Tex. 514...59 Tex. Cr. 7602.........138 Ky. 164 946.......148 Mo. A. 243

1180

Tex. Cv. A. 5-16...58 Tex. Cr. )

.138 Ky. 174
.143 Mo. A. 679

...Tex. Cv, A. 547...59 Tex. Cr.

765
......Ky. 949.......143 Mo. A. 683

11832 .... Tex. Cy. A. 548...68 Tex. Cr. R 767'.... 138 Ky. 180 950.......143 Mo. A. OS 1186

... Tex. Cv. A. 549...59 Tex. Cr. R 7672... 138 Ky, 181 951. ...95 Ark. 48

1189 ....Tex, Cv. A,
...Tex.
550. ....... Tex.
769.... ...138 Ky. 189

957.....
..94 Ark. 493 | 1192

.Tex. Cv. A.
...Ter
551'..59 Tex. Cr. 1

770.... ......138 Ky. 190 958..... ..94 Ark. 496 1194 .... Tex. Cr. A. ....Tex 551?..59 Tex. Cr. R 773..........138 Ky. 200

...94 Ark, 572 | 1199 ...Tex. Cv. A. .....Ter. 559...59 Tex. Cr. R. | 779..........138 Ky. 220 1960..........94 Ark. 575 1199

Tex. Cv. A .......Ten. A. 561• ....... Tex. Cv. A Not reported in State Reports. † Not reported in full in Official Reports; reported in full in the Southwestern Reporter

End of Table 1