even at the time when he himself lived and wrote. Completion of the poem by working it on to this actual and historical consummation was, therefore, simply impossible. But, in short, by publishing the poem as it stands, Milton certified its completeness according to his own idea of the theme and its capabilities.- "Well, then," some of the critics continue, raising a second question, "can the poem properly be called an epic?" They have in view the Iliad, the Odyssey, and the Æneid, as the types of epics; and, allowing that Paradise Lost may rank as also an epic, they think Paradise Regained too short and too simple for such a name. But Milton had anticipated the objection as early as 1641, when, in his Reason of Church-Government, speaking of his literary schemes, he had distinguished two kinds of epics, of either of which he might have the option if he should ultimately determine on the epic form of composition as the best for his genius. "That epick form," he had said, "whereof the two poems of Homer, and those other two of Virgil and Tasso, are a diffuse, and the Book of Job a brief, model." May we not say that, as in Paradise Lost he had adopted the larger or more diffuse of the two models of epic here described, so in Paradise Regained he had in view rather the smaller or briefer model? This would put the matter on its right basis. Paradise Regained is a different poem from Paradise Lost,--not so great, because not admitting of being so great; but it is as good in its different kind, artistically perfect in its pictorial clearness and coherence, and altogether one of the most edifying and full-bodied poems in any literature. The difference of kinds between the two epics is signalised in certain differences in the language and versification. Paradise Regained seems written more rapidly than Paradise Lost, and, though with passages of superlative beauty, yet with less avoidance of plain historical phrases, and less study of the effect of sustained song. Recovered Paradise to all mankind, By one man's firm obedience fully tried Through all temptation, and the Tempter foiled Thou Spirit, who led'st this glorious Eremite Against the spiritual foe, and brought'st him thence 10 And unrecorded left through many an age: Now had the great Proclaimer, with a voice VOL. III. C To him his heavenly office. Nor was long "O ancient Powers of Air and this wide World How many ages, as the years of men, This Universe we have possessed, and ruled Upon my head. Long the decrees of Heaven Delay, for longest time to Him is short; And now, too soon for us, the circling hours This dreaded time have compassed, wherein we Must bide the stroke of that long-threatened wound (At least, if so we can, and by the head Broken be not intended all our power To be infringed, our freedom and our being In this fair empire won of Earth and Air)— 30 40 50 60 |