 The judge has a certain duty to discharge, and the jurors have another and a different duty. The judge has to say whether any facts have been established by evidence from, which negligence may be reasonably inferred ; the jurors have to say whether, from...  Reports of Cases Decided in the Supreme Court of the State of North Dakota - 155 페이지저자: North Dakota. Supreme Court, Hiram A. Libby, Robert Milligan Carothers, Robert Dimon Hoskins, Edgar Whittlesey Camp, John McDowell Cochrane, Ames Francis Wilbur, Joseph Coghlan, Edwin James Taylor - 1914전체보기 - 도서 정보
 | Frederick Pollock - 1901 - 716 페이지
...and a different duty. The judge r"-v- has to say whether any facts have been established Jackson. JJ by evidence from which negligence may be reasonably...from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence oiu,Tht to be inferred. It is, in my opinion, of the greatest importance in the administration of justice... | |
 | Frank Farnum Dresser - 1902 - 906 페이지
...drawn from them are uncertain, and might fairly lead different minds to different conclusions."158 "The judge has to say whether any facts have been...reasonably inferred. The jurors have to say whether i08 McGhee v. Campbell (CCA) 101 Fed. 936, 940. "If the evidence, in the most favorable light in which... | |
 | 1902 - 1040 페이지
...defendant ought to have taken. See Hayes v. Michinan CR Co. Ill US 228 28' L. ed. 410. 4 Sup. Ct. Rep. 300. "The judge has a certain duty to discharge, and the jurors have another and different duty. The judge has to sny whether any facts have, been established by evidence from which... | |
 | Francis Reynolds Yonge Radcliffe, Sir John Charles Miles - 1904 - 648 페이지
...lordships' bar, any serious controversy as to the principles applicable to a case of this description. The judge has a certain duty to discharge, and the...from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is, in mj opinion, of the greatest importance to the administration of justice... | |
 | George Albert Bonner, Henry Gatchell Farrant - 1904 - 374 페이지
...principles have been stated by the House of Lords by Lord Cairns (»<) in the following language : — " The judge has a certain duty to discharge, and the...from those facts when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is, in my opinion, of the greatest importance in the administration of justice... | |
 | John Dawson Mayne - 1904 - 1186 페이지
...down by Lord Cairns, C., in a case which is now the governing decision upon this point. He said : " The judge has a certain duty to discharge, and the...from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence ought to be inferred. It is, in my opinion, of the greatest importance in the administration of justice... | |
 | 1904 - 828 페이지
...Chancellor 62 CCA— 8 Cairns in Metropolitan Ry. Co. v. Jackson, UR 3 App. Cases, 193, 197, where he said: "The Judge has to say •whether any facts have been established by evidence from which neglipence may reasonably be Inferred; the jurors have to say whether, from those facts when submitted... | |
 | Ratanlal Ranchhoddas, Dhirajlal Keshavlal Thakore - 1905 - 622 페이지
...(Dnary v. NE Ry^ (1901) 3 KB 322). Judge and jury. According to the English law it is for the Judge to say whether any facts have been established by...evidence from which negligence may be reasonably inferred ; and then it is for the jury to say whether, from those facts, when submitted to them, negligence... | |
 | 1905 - 954 페이지
...App. Cas. 193, that the duty of the trial judge, when requested to nonsuit or direct a verdict, is to say whether any facts have been established by...from which negligence may be reasonably inferred. If none, there is no case to go to the jury; but if, from the facts established, negligence may be... | |
 | Windward Islands (Jurisdiction). Court of Appeal - 1905 - 320 페이지
...I should more properly say, no evidence to go to the jury, for, as the LORD CHANCELLOR remarked, " The judge has a certain duty to discharge, and the jurors have another and a different duty ; and that it would be a serious inroad on the province of the jury, if, in a case where there are... | |
| |
